Connect with us

Man Utd General News

Should Manchester United Switch To 3-5-2?

Football-Talk contributor Bivlar looks at whether Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson should consider switching to a back three and predicts a line-up.

rio ferdinand

Having recognised that his midfield has been bossed by opponents, Sir Alex Ferguson has been seen to pack more numbers in there and employ the energy of Rooney. Whether it is the effective diamond against Newcastle, or the 4-1-4-1 against Chelsea last weekend, he is determined not to see his midfield get overrun as it was, notably, against Spurs at home earlier this season.

In this quest for achieving midfield dominance as well as sticking to United’s traditional wing play, Ferguson can take a leaf out of Cesare Prandelli’s book and toy with the idea of using a 3-5-2; a setup which saw the Italians frustrate Spain in the group fixture at the Euros. Such a system can let United attack with verve down the wings and pack the middle when not in possession, the latter being possible with the presence of three central midfielders. This system could also favour United’s leaky defence, with a spare man available – when it is a 3 v 2, or two against a lone striker.

Whilst playing against a 4-3-3, this system would help provide the wingbacks with more time and space on the ball as the three opposition forwards will tend to try and press the defenders. This would require opposition full backs to press further forward, which if done incorrectly, can leave them exposed.

United have the resources to make such a system work. Taking into account current injuries, a potential line up with 3 at the back could be:

Man Utd 3 at the back

In theory, teams playing with width can outnumber this set up on the flanks but given how most wide midfielders these days tend to drift inwards to get involved (for e.g. Nasri, Bale, Iniesta) or teams use a 4-3-3, the threat down the width can be dealt with relative simplicity. Presence of players with adept defensive capabilities like Valencia and Evra as wingbacks will also help to deal with opposition attacks down the wide areas.

Without the ball, Rooney can drop deeper and add more steel to the midfield whilst Carrick can drop deeper and shield the defence. Sergio Busquets does this role effectively for Barcelona though the former’s defensive capabilities could be a cause for concern as seen recently during stints in defence. When fit, Phil Jones can portray this role effectively with Carrick taking on one of the other positions in the middle.

A fully fit squad would give United endless options to fit in this system. Kagawa can play ‘in the hole’ (with Young and Welbeck also able to do so). Rooney, Anderson, and Scholes can take roles in the middle, with Nani, Buttner, Gigg or even Rafael playing the role of wingbacks (in case of the latter, United would need a fully fit quartet of central defenders to choose from).

Obviously, for a system to work effectively, the players need to have had played in it and be comfortable with it. City learnt this the hard way, losing to Ajax in the Champions league with Roberto Mancini trying to adopt a back 3 during the match. His reason behind the change was because Ajax played with only one striker but the players didn’t either have the experience or tactical intelligence to play in such a system.

Tactical flexibility might be a necessity with more teams identifying United’s weakness in the middle but application of unfamiliarity could prove to be a kamikaze tactic. Introduction of the 3-5-2 or similar system should be done only once numerous training ground trials have been done and Sir Alex feels the players are ready for such a system.

Do you think United should consider a switch to a back 3? Get involved in the comments section.

Fancy a flutter on the game? Claim your £10 welcome bonus at Sky Bet and enjoy some of the best match odds in the business.



  1. eer

    November 4, 2012 at 10:44 am

    think the diamond united have been playing recently is similar to a 352 with carrick or fletcher playing so deep and evra and rafael playing as wing backs

    de gea
    ferdy evans
    rafael evra
    clevs ando

  2. Pre Munich Red

    November 4, 2012 at 11:38 am

    All this talk about systems can get too technical. Fergie is tactically brilliant and will change the formation regularly to fit a particular situation. He has made sure that he has built a squad of players who are fluid and can adapt on a match by match basis and it has worked. Remember that but for a Drogba goal that was offside in 2010 and a last kick of the game goal from City last year we would now be going for our SEVENTH title on the bounce. All of that was achieved by being able to adapt our game on a match by match basis. Despite what is often claimed we were never completely obsessed by a rigid 4:4:2 system.

  3. richard

    November 4, 2012 at 12:37 pm

    Well said, Pre Munich Red–well said!

  4. Atu Alfred

    November 4, 2012 at 1:10 pm

    I dont like that formation, lets make use of eather 4-3-3 or 4-4-2 formation thanks.

  5. Ala

    November 4, 2012 at 2:07 pm

    De Gea
    Smalling Ferdinand Evans

    Carrick Cleverley
    Valencia Welbeck

    Van Persie

  6. Pingback: Man United to honour manager Ferguson with statue – Reuters UK | Manchester United News and Bets

  7. Pingback: Man United to honour manager Ferguson with statue – Reuters UK | Red Devils Online

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Other News

More in Man Utd General News